
If you have followed me for some time, you know that pumpkin pie spice is my all-time favorite spice. The warm blend of cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, and cloves instantly makes me think of crisp fall mornings, delicious pumpkin-spiced hot drinks, and tasty autumnal treats. Every year, I look for new ways to bring that flavor into my kitchen—and this time, I wanted to do something a little different.
The idea of making pumpkin spice dough popped into my head, but since I follow the carnivore diet (with occasional seasonings and sweeteners), I try to avoid fiber-heavy ingredients. That meant no real pumpkin puree, no nut flours, and no nut butters either—even though I’ve used those plenty of times in my countless pumpkin and fall-themed keto dough recipes across this blog. This time, I wanted something that was truly animal-based, low-fiber, and still indulgent.
So, I decided to try just butter and vanilla-flavored whey protein isolate as the base, plus a pastured egg yolk for fluffiness. Naturally, I included a keto-friendly sweetener (my own blend of powdered erythritol and stevia), and of course, a heaping spoonful of heavenly pumpkin pie spice. To my delight, the experiment turned out absolutely perfect. The texture was buttery yet firm, just like dough, and the flavor was pure fall comfort.
Best of all, this recipe is no-bake, has only five ingredients, and is 100% ketovore-friendly. It’s also perfect for carnivores—if you’re open to using seasonings and sweeteners in your diet. I was so much enjoying the fall flavors—and my tummy too!
…









