
Back in May 2024, Truly Carnivore Ice Cream proved that you didn’t even need an ice cream maker to make something outrageously good. No churning, no fuss, just cream and egg yolks doing their thing. It was easy, straightforward, and far better than anyone expected from such a minimal setup.
Then, two weeks ago, in January 2026, Carnivore Blue Cheese Ice Cream entered the picture. That recipe was built on a cooked custard base, and while it worked beautifully, it really came into its own when churned. The texture was smoother, lighter, and more refined, and it made one thing painfully clear.
Churning matters.
Once I realized what churning does to a cream-and-egg-yolk custard, there was no unseeing it. So, I took the purity and simplicity of my Truly Carnivore Ice Cream, combined it with the custard technique from the blue cheese version, removed the cheese itself, and churned the result properly.
The outcome is The Ultimate Carnivore Ice Cream. Same uncompromising ingredients, dramatically better texture. If Truly Carnivore Ice Cream made waves back in 2024, this one is here to make the whole carnivore internet lose its balance.
The base recipe is strictly animal-based, without a single plant sneaking in through the back door. That said, if you’re keto rather than hardcore carnivore, don’t worry. I saved the rule-bending for the Tips for Variations section at the end.
…









