
Let’s get this out of the way immediately: yes, this is Carnivore Blue Cheese Ice Cream. And no, I haven’t lost my mind. Or maybe I have — but if I did, it was in the best possible way.
This recipe is based on my super popular Truly Carnivore Ice Cream, which apparently taught us all an important lesson: if you give carnivores heavy cream and egg yolks, we will do anything. Including things that sound completely wrong on paper and turn out disturbingly good in real life.
My fascination with blue cheese ice cream actually goes way back. I first encountered it in the 1990s, when I was living in Helsinki. There was this special Italian ice cream parlor I used to pass regularly, and one flavor always stopped me in my tracks: blue cheese ice cream. I don’t even remember if I ever tasted it back then, but I was endlessly intrigued by the idea.
Fast‑forward almost 30 years, and I finally made it myself. And tasted it. And yes, it was absolutely worth the wait. Indulgent, creamy, rich, and pure heaven. Less dessert, more luxury frozen cheese course — and far better than my imagination ever gave it credit for.
Before anyone panics, I’ve included plenty of tips for variations. And yes, some of those variations contain no blue cheese at all, for those of you who love carnivore ice cream but draw the line at frozen moldy dairy. You’re welcome.
So if you’re feeling adventurous — or just curious enough to keep reading — let’s make some carnivore ice cream that will confuse your friends and completely win you over.
…









